6 Factors to Consider When Choosing an Influencer for Your Marketing Campaign

January 11, 2023

6-factors-to-consider-when-choosing-an-influencer-for-your-marketing-campaign banner

11 January 2023 — Merr Fe Painagan

Influencer marketing is a powerful way to reach and engage with new audiences, and it can be a highly effective component of a marketing campaign. However, choosing the right influencer for your campaign is crucial to its success.

There are many factors to consider when selecting an influencer, from their audience and reach to their authenticity and fit with your brand. In this article, we will explore the top 6 factors that you should consider when choosing an influencer for your marketing campaign.

By carefully evaluating these key considerations, you can find the influencer who is the best fit for your brand and will help you effectively reach and engage with your target audience.


Micro influencers and nano influencers are often more effective for marketing campaigns because they have smaller but highly engaged audiences and are experts in their niches. This means that they are more likely to create authentic content that aligns with a brand’s message. It’s also important for brands to avoid working with influencers who have a history of buying fake followers, as this can negatively impact the effectiveness of the influencer marketing campaign. Brands want influencers to have genuine, engaged audiences in order to maximize the reach and impact of their campaigns.

An influencer’s authenticity is important because it helps to build trust and credibility with their audience. If an influencer is perceived as real and genuine in their content and interactions, their followers are more likely to trust their recommendations and be influenced by their opinions.

Recommended Read: 4 Ways to Use Storytelling to Create Authentic Content for Your Influencer Marketing Campaign


When selecting an influencer for your marketing campaign, it’s important to consider how closely their content aligns with your brand’s targeted keywords. This will help ensure that the partnership is mutually beneficial and that the influencer is genuinely interested in or supportive of your brand. In recent years, many marketers have turned to micro influencers and nano influencers, who have smaller but highly engaged and relevant audiences, to help reach and engage with niche audiences. 

Another aspect of relevance to consider is the influencer’s affinity for your industry – for example, if your brand is a fashion brand, you may want to choose an influencer who has a reputation for working with fashion brands in the past.


To be an effective influencer, it’s important to have a sustained presence on social media and connect with your audience. This means posting regularly and engaging with your followers. It’s also important to promote your content, stay up-to-date on trends, and interact with your fans. However, it’s important to avoid over-promoting brands or products, as this can come across as spammy and inauthentic. 

According to a study, 61% of people have unfollowed an influencer who worked with “inappropriate” brands or endorsed too many products. To maintain credibility, it’s important to only promote brands or products that you genuinely believe in and to avoid overdoing it.


It’s important for brands to consider how much interaction an influencer’s content receives when choosing them for a marketing campaign. This is called engagement, and it can include likes, comments, and shares. Influencers with high engagement rates are more likely to help a brand’s campaign reach a wider audience and be more successful. For example, an influencer with 100,000 followers who charges $1,000 per post but only has a low engagement rate of 1.5% may not be as effective as an influencer with 50,000 followers who charges $500 per post but has a high engagement rate of 10%. This is because the second influencer’s content is more likely to be shared and seen by more people. In general, influencers with smaller audiences, called micro influencers and nano influencers, tend to have higher engagement rates because they can better connect with their followers.

PopStar Case Study: How to Hit a 10% Engagement Rate for Your Influencer Marketing Campaign


While it might be tempting to choose an influencer with a large following on social media, it’s important to remember that their audience should align with your target demographic in order for the partnership to be effective. To ensure that you are reaching the right people, start by creating customer personas for your brand to identify the age groups, locations, and interests of your key customer segments. Then, look for influencers who have audiences that match these characteristics. An influencer with a smaller but highly relevant following can be more effective for your marketing campaign than one with a large but unrelated audience.


For an influencer marketing campaign to be successful, it’s important to target the right location. If your company’s product or service is only available in a specific region, it wouldn’t be an effective use of resources to hire an influencer with a following in another part of the world. To make sure you are reaching the right market, consider searching for influencers who are based in the locations where your product or service is available and have a relevant follower base. By focusing on the right location, you can maximize the impact of your campaign.

Final PopStar Tip

To ensure the success of your influencer marketing campaign, it is essential to choose an influencer who aligns with your brand and will effectively reach and engage your target audience. Factors such as authenticity, relevance, activity, engagement, and audience demographics should be carefully considered in order to select the best fit for your campaign. 

Additionally, it is important to avoid working with influencers who have bought fake followers or excessively promote products, as this can negatively impact your campaign’s performance. By considering these key factors, you can find the ideal influencer to help you achieve your influencer marketing goals.

Recommended Read: Social Media Campaign Trends: Outlook for 2023

Visit www.pop-star.me or you can message or contact our Team at contact@pop-star.me for more information on how PopStar can help you in choosing the right influencer for your influencer marketing campaign.

section three background

Work with PopStar!

Start your Influencer Marketing Campaign and work with the top Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook influencers in the Indonesia and Philippines!